Social and hospital barriers lengthen stroke treatment delays in Indonesia

A systematic review in BMJ Open pulls together a troubling pattern in acute ischaemic stroke care across Indonesia: patients do not arrive quickly enough, and once they do arrive, treatment often still moves too slowly. Across 27 studies and 3,610 patients, the most consistent barriers sat both outside the hospital and inside it, where geography, money, health literacy, and system friction all pushed reperfusion and evaluation farther from the point where brain tissue might still be saved.

The review followed PRISMA methods, searched 11 databases plus ClinicalTrials.gov registries and three preprint repositories through October 2024, and used the Risk of Bias in Non-randomised Studies of Exposures tool to assess study quality. Two reviewers extracted data independently, then synthesized the evidence using a combining p values approach and albatross plots. In a field where randomized trials are often impossible and delay pathways are shaped by local infrastructure, that kind of synthesis matters because the problem is not one variable but a chain of failures that can begin at symptom onset and continue until treatment decisions are made.

Education, income, and belief systems shaped the first hours after stroke onset

Prehospital delay emerged as a social as well as medical problem. Low educational level was associated with delay across six studies, with a p value of 0.014. Low socioeconomic status showed a similar association across five studies, with p=0.003. Cultural beliefs affecting decision-making also appeared repeatedly, although the abstract truncates the full statistic at p=, leaving the broader direction of effect intact but not the final numeric detail.

In stroke care, those associations are clinically intuitive and biologically consequential. The occlusion of a cerebral artery is time-sensitive from the first minute, yet the decision to seek help is rarely made in a vacuum. Limited health literacy can delay recognition of facial droop, arm weakness, aphasia, or sudden gait disturbance. Financial constraints can slow transport or create hesitation about hospital costs. Cultural frameworks may redirect families toward home observation, prayer, or informal consultation before emergency care is activated. Every one of those delays reduces the chance that acute ischaemic stroke therapy will begin within a window where neurologic salvage remains possible.

A one-sentence truth runs through the data: time lost before the hospital door is often time lost forever.

Hospital flow problems added a second layer of delay

The review did not stop at prehospital barriers. In-hospital delays were also tied to measurable process failures, including a longer time from door to hospital arrival and longer time from hospital arrival to stroke team assessment. Those delays are not abstract administrative metrics. They usually reflect the cumulative effect of triage bottlenecks, limited stroke-team availability, delayed neuroimaging, and uneven coordination between emergency staff and neurologists or stroke units.

Stroke systems depend on compression of every interval after arrival. If triage misses the diagnosis, if the patient waits for imaging, or if consultation is slow, the therapeutic clock keeps moving while the infarct core expands. In a condition where clot-related hypoperfusion can rapidly convert threatened tissue into irretrievable injury, in-hospital delays can erase the benefit of the patient’s fast departure from home. The review’s findings reinforce that door-to-needle performance cannot be separated from public education campaigns, ambulance access, and emergency department organization; all of them sit on the same pathway.

What the pooled evidence suggests about stroke systems in Indonesia

The review assembled evidence from a geographically and methodologically diverse body of work, and the signal was consistent enough to support a clear health-system interpretation. Patients with fewer social resources were less likely to move quickly into care, while hospitals often introduced additional waiting time even after presentation. For policy makers, this points to a dual intervention strategy rather than a single fix. Community-based recognition campaigns may help families identify stroke earlier, but those efforts will not be sufficient if emergency departments still struggle to move patients from the front door to specialist review and imaging.

Indonesia’s stroke burden likely magnifies the consequence of these delays because ischemic stroke rewards speed more than almost any other neurologic emergency. Thrombolysis and thrombectomy are both highly time dependent, and even modest delays can narrow eligibility or worsen final disability. The review therefore has direct bedside relevance: stroke teams cannot rely on patient presentation alone, because the social conditions preceding arrival already shape prognosis before the first CT scan is ordered.

Why the review matters for clinicians and health planners

The practical value of this review lies in its separation of delay into two linked domains. Prehospital delay is driven by recognition, beliefs, education, and socioeconomic position. In-hospital delay is driven by systems performance. When both operate together, the result is predictable: fewer patients arrive in time for definitive treatment, and those who do arrive may still lose critical minutes before assessment.

Because the evidence base came from observational studies, the review cannot prove that any single factor causes delay in every setting. It does, however, map the most plausible and repeatedly observed barriers in Indonesian stroke care. That makes the findings useful for triage redesign, public health messaging, emergency routing, and stroke-team activation protocols. Hospitals serving large catchment areas may need faster bedside screening and more direct escalation pathways, while community programs may need to speak more plainly about symptom recognition and the urgency of emergency transport rather than routine clinic referral.

The review closes one question and opens another. The pattern of delay is now visible; the next challenge is deciding which combination of community education, transport reform, and hospital process redesign can shorten it enough to change outcomes.

Journal reference and evidence base

The review was published in BMJ Open in 2025 under DOI 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-095845. It searched 11 databases, ClinicalTrials.gov registries, and three preprint repositories through October 2024, and it included 27 studies totaling 3,610 patients.

Even without randomized intervention data, the message is direct: in Indonesia, stroke care is still being slowed by the combined weight of social disadvantage and hospital bottlenecks. The infarct does not wait for the system to catch up.


Reporting by Dr. A. Manasa, MBBS for Medicine World Foundation, with additional data provided by BMJ Open.
PRIMARY CLINICAL EVIDENCE & REGISTRY DATA