Participatory action research lifted most geriatric care indicators in Yazd, but reach lagged behind
Iran’s Integrated Geriatric Care Program received a structured stress test in Yazd County, and the program’s performance moved upward after each cycle of local redesign. In this participatory action research study, investigators used a concurrent mixed-methods approach to examine how well the program was functioning inside the primary care system and then iteratively revised it with health care providers. The result was not a single dramatic overhaul but a stepwise improvement pattern: the total standardized RE-AIM score rose from 54.05 ± 8.09 at baseline to 67.23 ± 5.89 after the Proposed Intervention Plan and then to 81.98 ± 6.61 after the Modified Proposed Intervention Plan.
The signal was strongest in the overall program score. It moved upward after both intervention cycles, and the statistical testing supported those changes with P < 0.001 across the study steps. In practical terms, this means the geriatric care model became more complete, more coordinated, or both, as the action plan was refined and reintroduced. The findings fit the biology and logistics of aging care: older adults rarely present with one isolated condition, and systems that screen for hypertension, nutrition problems, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, depression, fall risk, and cancer risk have to work as an interconnected pathway rather than as a set of disconnected checklists.
A weak starting point in reach shaped the entire intervention
The most stubborn problem sat inside the reach dimension. Despite improvements in the other RE-AIM domains, reach did not change significantly, with P = 0.122. That is a sharp reminder that a program can become better organized without automatically becoming broader in coverage. If older adults are not being identified, engaged, or brought into the system at the front end, later-stage gains in care quality will still leave too many people outside the net.
The investigators used the RE-AIM framework to evaluate the program before and after each action cycle, and they built the work around six sequential steps spread across two rounds of participatory change. The first round covered problem identification, planning, implementation of the Proposed Intervention Plan, and then evaluation and revision. The second round repeated the cycle with the Modified Proposed Intervention Plan and a final evaluation. Each intervention period lasted four months. That structure matters because geriatric care improvement in primary care settings often depends less on a single policy declaration than on repeated feedback loops, local adaptation, and provider buy-in.
Small-provider sampling still produced a clear before-and-after pattern
The study relied on Electronic Health Records and a researcher-made questionnaire completed by all healthcare providers involved, a group of nine. Even with a small provider sample, the repeated-measures design captured a consistent directional change across the program. Friedman’s test showed significant differences among the five RE-AIM dimensions at each step, with P ≤ 0.002, while repeated measures ANOVA and post hoc testing confirmed the progressive increase in the total standardized score. The data suggest that the intervention did not simply improve one isolated metric; it altered multiple components of program delivery in tandem.
One especially notable result was the increase in the Complete Care indicator, which reached 20.78% after the initial intervention. For geriatric care, complete care is not a trivial operational term. It reflects whether older adults are actually receiving the sequence of screening, assessment, follow-up, and management steps that integrated programs promise. When a program climbs on paper but stops short of complete delivery, the gap is often administrative rather than biological: missed appointments, incomplete documentation, weak referral pathways, or inconsistent provider routines can interrupt the chain.
Why participatory action research fits geriatric care redesign
Participatory action research is well suited to a setting like this because geriatric care is inherently local. The needs of older adults in one county are shaped by staffing, referral flow, family structure, access barriers, and the way primary health centers actually operate day to day. By bringing providers into the cycle of identifying problems, revising the plan, and testing the modified version, the model creates ownership rather than top-down compliance. It also allows health systems to adjust interventions to the realities of community resources, which is often the difference between a program that looks strong on paper and one that performs at the bedside or in the clinic.
The broader public health logic is straightforward. As populations age, primary care systems become the front line for detecting chronic disease, preserving function, and preventing avoidable decline. Integrated geriatric programs are designed to do exactly that, but implementation quality determines whether they reach older adults consistently. The Yazd experience shows that iterative, locally guided redesign can improve performance, yet it also shows that some bottlenecks are resistant. Reach, in particular, may require different tactics than those used to improve internal workflow or care completeness.
What the Yazd data can and cannot answer
The study offers a clear operational lesson: iterative redesign can raise integrated geriatric care performance, but not every weak link responds at the same pace. A program may gain in total standardized score and still leave its access funnel unchanged. For policymakers, that means future work should not stop at internal efficiency; it should also address identification, outreach, and enrollment of older adults who never enter the program at all.
The analysis also has a narrow clinical horizon. The evaluation focused on program indicators and RE-AIM dimensions, not on downstream patient-level outcomes such as hospitalization, functional independence, or mortality. The current findings therefore speak to service delivery performance rather than to hard health endpoints. Even so, the upward shift in total score after the modified intervention suggests that structured feedback and adaptation can strengthen the infrastructure of geriatric care, especially when local providers help design the fix.
The most important unresolved issue is whether stronger program mechanics will translate into measurable gains for older adults over time. Until that is tested, Yazd offers a careful but encouraging implementation result: integrated geriatric care can be improved, but the path to broader reach remains unfinished.
- • PLOS One article DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0362746: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0362746