One in four discharged emergency patients had a catheter with no documented intravenous need
In a busy emergency department, the decision to place a short peripheral catheter can happen in minutes and often before the full treatment plan is clear. This study from Hospital Manacor in Mallorca shows how often that default step may overshoot the actual clinical need: among 1488 discharged adults with a recorded catheter, 388 patients, or 26.1%, had no documented intravenous medication, fluids, or other intravenous treatment during the entire emergency department episode.
The finding lands in a practical zone of patient safety and resource use. A peripheral line is small, but it is not neutral. It adds a puncture, a device to maintain, a source of discomfort, and a small but real exposure to avoidable complications when it is inserted without a treatment indication. In an environment where rapid throughput often favors readiness over restraint, this cohort suggests that some catheters are being placed as a habit of workflow rather than as a response to a documented need.
How the study defined potentially unnecessary catheter insertion
Investigators used retrospective, systematic time-based sampling across 47 calendar days in 2023 at a secondary-care hospital emergency department. Adults who were discharged and had a recorded SPC were included. The primary outcome was narrow and clinically concrete: no documented intravenous medication, fluids, or any other intravenous treatment during the complete emergency department episode. A secondary, more permissive classification expanded the definition to include patients who received only one selected intravenous treatment with potential non-intravenous alternatives.
Under that broader lens, 616 patients, or 41.4%, fell into the potentially unnecessary category. The jump from 26.1% to 41.4% is striking. It suggests that the apparent need for vascular access becomes even shakier once treatments with oral or other non-intravenous options are considered, which is exactly where bedside variation tends to hide. A catheter inserted “just in case” may feel harmless at the moment, but this dataset shows how quickly that instinct can move a large share of patients into a low-value intervention bucket.
Age, sex, and triage markers shaped the odds
Older age was associated with higher odds of the primary outcome, with an odds ratio of 1.03 per year and a 95% confidence interval of 1.02 to 1.04. In plain clinical terms, catheter insertion without a documented intravenous treatment became more common as age increased. That pattern may reflect caution around older adults, greater diagnostic uncertainty, or a tendency to secure access preemptively in patients perceived as more fragile. None of those explanations can be proven from this dataset alone, but the direction of effect is consistent with a familiar emergency department reflex: reserve access first, justify it later.
Female sex was associated with lower odds of the primary outcome, with an odds ratio of 0.73 and a 95% confidence interval of 0.58 to 0.91. The study does not explain why, and the result should not be overread as a biologic difference. More likely, it reflects differences in presentation, clinician behavior, or treatment pathways that were not fully captured in the charted variables.
Clinical urgency added another layer. A one-level decrease in urgency was not associated with the outcome in the unadjusted model, but became associated after adjustment for triage presentation syndrome or discharge diagnosis syndrome. Each syndrome variable was associated with the outcome in its respective model, and the global p values were significant for those syndrome terms. The analytic message is straightforward: the type of presentation matters, and it matters enough that broad urgency scores alone do not fully explain catheter placement decisions. When the presentation syndrome is folded into the model, the clinical signal sharpens.
Emergency department access habits may be driving avoidable procedures
The study does not measure catheter-related complications, length of stay, or downstream cost, so it cannot quantify the full harm of unnecessary insertion. Even so, the clinical implication is hard to miss. If a quarter of discharged patients with a catheter never receive intravenous therapy, then a meaningful share of patients are exposed to an invasive procedure that does not appear to have been needed for treatment delivery.
That is especially relevant in emergency medicine, where vascular access is often created at the front end of care to avoid delay later. The workflow advantage is real. Yet preemptive placement can become self-perpetuating: once a line is in place, clinicians may be more likely to use it, which can encourage intravenous treatment even when an oral option would have been sufficient. This study does not prove that cycle, but it fits the clinical logic of overused access.
The expanded definition is also important because it reaches beyond the strictest reading of intravenous necessity. Some patients received a single intravenous therapy that had potential non-intravenous alternatives. That gray zone is where many emergency department decisions live, and it is also where standardization could probably help the most. Protocols that clarify when oral medication, observation, or no line at all is appropriate could reduce catheter placement without restricting legitimate care.
A single-centre snapshot with useful operational signal
This was a retrospective, single-centre observational study, so its results should not be treated as a universal benchmark. Practice patterns in one hospital, one region, and one sampling strategy may differ from those elsewhere. Still, the size of the cohort and the consistency of the signal make the finding operationally relevant. Even with conservative classification, potentially unnecessary short peripheral catheter insertion was common.
For emergency clinicians, the message is not to abandon vascular access. It is to tighten the threshold for placing it in discharged patients when no intravenous treatment is documented or when the only treatment could reasonably have been delivered by another route. Small procedural habits often escape scrutiny because they are so embedded in routine care. This study puts a number on that habit and shows that the gap between access and actual use is large enough to matter.
DOI
The study was published in BMJ Open in 2026. The article DOI is 10.1136/bmjopen-2026-120995. Future work will need to determine whether reducing low-value catheter placement can lower discomfort, device-related complications, and avoidable consumption of nursing time without slowing emergency department flow.
- • BMJ Open study DOI 10.1136/bmjopen-2026-120995: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2026-120995