Preceptors in Islamabad delivered strong clinical teaching, but support outside the task remained thin

Clinical teaching behaviours from preceptors of undergraduate nursing students were largely rated positively in a tertiary teaching hospital in Islamabad, yet one clear weakness emerged: personalised support lagged behind professional guidance. In a setting where bedside learning determines whether theoretical instruction becomes safe practice, that split matters for the next generation of nurses. The study used a convergent mixed-methods design, bringing student ratings and preceptor interviews into the same analytic frame rather than treating them as separate stories.

Across the quantitative arm, 44 undergraduate nursing students contributed 88 student-preceptor encounter observations. Mean scores on the CTB Inventory ranged from 3.48 to 3.97 on a 5-point scale, placing the overall teaching profile on the positive side of the ledger. The strongest domain was guiding interprofessional communication, which reached a mean of 3.97 with an SD of 0.89. In practical terms, students saw preceptors modeling how nurses speak with physicians, allied professionals and other clinical staff—a skill that affects escalation, teamwork and patient safety at the bedside.

One sentence captures the tension in the data: preceptors were strongest where visible clinical competence was easiest to demonstrate, and weakest where time, attention and emotional availability were required.

Role modelling and structured teaching carried the strongest ratings

Students gave particularly high ratings to professional role modelling, with 85.2% agreeing that preceptors demonstrated it. In nursing education, role modelling is not an abstract teaching virtue; it is the mechanism by which students learn what competent conduct looks like under pressure. A preceptor who communicates clearly, stays composed, and shows disciplined bedside practice teaches more than any checklist can capture. The integrated findings also aligned around structured teaching, scaffolded learning, feedback, and communication practices, suggesting that students recognized a coherent teaching style rather than isolated good moments.

The qualitative interviews with 14 preceptors help explain why those domains scored well. Six categories emerged: commitment to teaching, learning environment creation, instructional strategies, communication facilitation, feedback and evaluation, and supportive behaviours. Those categories point to teachers who saw education as part of their clinical identity, not as an interruption to service delivery. When a preceptor creates a learning environment inside a busy ward, the educational effect can be immediate: students are more likely to ask questions, observe carefully, and attempt skills with supervision rather than imitation alone.

The study’s design strengthens the interpretation. By collecting quantitative and qualitative data concurrently, analyzing them independently, and then integrating them through the Pillar Integration Process, the investigators could identify where the two data streams reinforced each other and where they diverged. That structure produced a more complete picture of clinical teaching than either method could provide on its own.

Personalised support fell behind because the ward competed for attention

The lowest-rated domain was showing concern and support, with a mean score of 3.48 and SD of 0.89. Only 31.8% of students agreed that preceptors showed concern about their lives outside work. This is a narrow but meaningful gap. Students may accept firm instruction, correction, and high standards; they are less likely to feel anchored in a training relationship when the teacher appears emotionally distant or too rushed to notice strain.

Preceptors themselves offered a direct explanation. Heavy workloads, competing clinical responsibilities, and limited protected teaching time constrained their ability to provide individualized support. In a high-throughput hospital environment, those pressures are not cosmetic barriers. They shape what kinds of teaching are feasible. A preceptor who must simultaneously supervise care, manage ward demands, and protect patient safety will often default to task-based instruction. Personal check-ins, mentoring conversations, and reflective debriefing become the first items sacrificed.

This pattern has obvious bedside implications. Nursing students who do not receive enough personal support may still learn procedures, but they can miss the confidence-building dimension that makes clinical competence sustainable. The transition from observer to practitioner depends on more than technical correction. It also depends on whether the learner feels seen, guided, and safe enough to disclose uncertainty.

The mixed-methods integration exposed both agreement and friction

The integrated analysis yielded six overarching themes and showed convergence in several core areas: professional role modelling, structured teaching, scaffolded learning, feedback, and communication practices. Those are the core ingredients of effective clinical instruction. Students recognized them, and preceptors described them. The overlap suggests that many teaching behaviours were visible and intentional rather than accidental.

Divergence appeared most clearly around personalised support. The students’ lower ratings did not contradict the preceptors’ accounts; they clarified them. Preceptors described supportive intentions, but the ward environment limited how fully those intentions could be expressed. In other words, the gap was not simply about attitude. It was about capacity, time, and institutional structure. A nurse may value teaching deeply and still struggle to offer consistent individual attention when the unit is stretched.

This kind of divergence is useful because it reveals where educational reform should be directed. Training a preceptor to use better teaching language will help, but it will not fully solve a workload-driven deficit in mentorship. If institutions want more consistent learner support, they need conditions that make that support realistic: protected teaching time, recognition of the preceptor role, and policies that treat education as part of clinical service rather than an optional extra.

Protected time and institutional recognition are the pressure points

The conclusions point toward three practical levers: preceptor training, institutional recognition, and supportive policies. Each one addresses a different part of the problem. Training can sharpen feedback skills and make instructional methods more consistent. Recognition can reinforce the value of the preceptor role and reduce the sense that teaching is invisible labor. Policy support can create the time and staffing conditions needed for individualized supervision.

For undergraduate nursing education, the stakes are straightforward. Students develop professional identity in the same spaces where they learn to administer care, communicate across disciplines, and respond to uncertainty. If those spaces are dominated by haste, the teaching will naturally tilt toward immediate tasks and away from reflection or reassurance. If they are supported, preceptors can do more than supervise; they can model the habits that define safe, collaborative nursing practice.

The study was limited to a tertiary teaching hospital in Islamabad and included 44 students in the quantitative analysis and 14 preceptors in the interviews. Those boundaries matter because teaching behaviour is shaped by local staffing, institutional culture, and clinical workload. Even so, the dataset offers a clear message: preceptors were effective in visible clinical instruction, but the system did not always permit sustained personal support. The next question for nursing education in similar settings is whether institutions can make that support routine rather than exceptional.


Reporting by Dr. A. Nikhil Krishnan, MBBS for Medicine World Foundation, with additional data provided by BMJ Open.