Nurse managers in Iran reported greater clinical leadership needs than staff nurses
In five teaching hospitals in Ardabil, Iran, a cross-sectional comparison drew a sharp line between how staff nurses and nurse managers view clinical leadership needs. The gap was not subtle. Nurse managers recorded a significantly higher adjusted mean score on the Clinical Leadership Needs Analysis instrument than staff nurses, with adjusted means of 302.32 and 258.18, respectively, and an F value of 165.39 with p < 0.001.
The finding points to a familiar but often underexamined problem in hospital systems: leadership expectations are not experienced evenly across the workforce. Nurses working at the bedside encounter leadership as day-to-day coordination, escalation, and clinical judgment under pressure. Managers carry those same demands, then absorb additional responsibility for staffing, oversight, accountability, and institutional performance. In that setting, higher perceived leadership needs may reflect a broader organizational burden rather than a simple deficit in skill.
Different roles, different pressures
The study included 374 staff nurses selected by proportional stratified random sampling and 76 nurse managers recruited by census. Researchers used a demographic questionnaire alongside the Persian version of the Clinical Leadership Needs Analysis instrument, then analyzed the data with ANCOVA and separate dummy-coded multiple linear regression models in SPSS v.26. The design was descriptive and cross-sectional, so it captured a snapshot of perception rather than a change over time. Even so, the size of the gap between groups suggests more than a small administrative nuance.
The differences make clinical sense. Staff nurses often work within tightly bounded tasks and protocols, where leadership needs may be perceived as support for communication, delegation, and team functioning. Nurse managers operate in a more expansive domain, where leadership includes strategic decision-making, conflict resolution, staffing adequacy, and maintaining quality across competing demands. A higher score in that group can plausibly signal greater exposure to leadership strain, deeper awareness of organizational gaps, or both.
Education and employment security shaped perceptions
Within the staff nurse model, the regression explained 23.9% of the variance in perceived leadership needs, with p < 0.001. Among the categorical predictors, holding a Master’s degree or higher was the only significant factor, with β = 0.465 and p < 0.001. Higher educational attainment may sharpen awareness of what clinical leadership requires, especially when advanced training exposes nurses to broader systems thinking, evidence-based practice, and responsibility beyond routine bedside work.
The nurse manager model told a different story and captured far more of the variance, with R2 = 0.668 and p < 0.001. Marital status was associated with perception in this group, with being married linked to higher perceived needs (β = 0.194, p = 0.047). Employment conditions carried even more weight. Non-permanent employment statuses, including Contractual and Commitment arrangements, were associated with significantly lower perceived needs than permanent employment, with p values at or below 0.009.
Those employment findings deserve careful reading. Job security can shape whether managers feel able to invest in long-range leadership development or whether their attention is consumed by short-term stability. Permanent employment may bring greater responsibility and a stronger sense of organizational ownership, which can raise awareness of leadership requirements. By contrast, non-permanent status may narrow a manager’s focus to immediate role survival and reduce perceived access to the authority that clinical leadership demands.
Why perceived leadership need is not the same as leadership competence
A central interpretive point runs through the analysis: perceived need is not the same as measured competence. The study’s conclusions argue that the differences likely arise from role-specific organizational responsibilities rather than objectively assessed leadership ability. That distinction matters in hospital planning. Training programs built on the assumption that all nurses share the same leadership gaps risk misallocating time and resources.
In practical terms, a staff nurse may need leadership development centered on communication, delegation, and rapid coordination within the care team. A nurse manager may need support in systems leadership, workforce planning, and sustaining authority under administrative pressure. When these groups are treated as a single audience, education risks becoming generic and less useful at the bedside and in management alike.
The data also hint at a deeper organizational mechanism. When leadership is distributed unevenly, perceptions of need often track exposure to responsibility rather than abstract professional identity. Managers who sit closer to staffing shortages, performance scrutiny, and interdepartmental conflict may experience leadership as an urgent operational tool. Staff nurses may see it as a professional growth domain, important but less central to immediate workflow. Both views are valid, and both require separate educational responses.
Training programs should separate bedside leadership from managerial leadership
The study’s main lesson is not that one group lacks leadership and the other possesses it. The more useful reading is that the two groups occupy different points in the same organizational chain, and their educational needs diverge accordingly. A single leadership curriculum is unlikely to serve both well. Hospitals that want to strengthen leadership capacity should build distinct pathways for staff nurses and nurse managers, with content matched to responsibility, authority, and working conditions.
The absence of external funding and the authors’ declaration of no competing interests keep the report straightforward, but the design still has the limits of a cross-sectional survey. It cannot determine whether education, marriage, or employment status causes the differences observed, and it cannot tell whether the scores shift after formal leadership training or organizational reform. The sample came from five teaching hospitals in one Iranian city, so transferability to other health systems should be made cautiously.
Even with those constraints, the pattern is clear enough to matter operationally. Clinical leadership is being perceived differently across nursing roles, and those perceptions are tied to education and job structure. Any institution that wants better leadership at the bedside will need to build programs that recognize how nurses and nurse managers experience responsibility in very different ways.