Trenching reduced blast vibration, but the slope still failed in every model run
At Sierra Leone’s Koidu Mine, trenching separated two problems that mining operators often hope will move together: structural vibration and slope stability. They did not. The numerical model showed a clear drop in peak particle velocity at nearby surface structures as trench depth increased, yet the same blast loading drove the open-pit slope to failure across all trench configurations tested.
The baseline, no-trench scenario produced a PPV of 7.94 mm/s at the nearest surface structure, 50 m from the blasthole. That value sat below the USBM RI 8507 limit of 12.7 mm/s, but it still exceeded the stricter DIN 4150-3 guideline of 5 mm/s for sensitive structures. In practical terms, the mine could remain below one commonly cited damage threshold while still crossing another that is more conservative for vulnerable buildings. The vibration problem was therefore real even before slope behavior entered the picture.
The simulation framework, built in ANSYS LS-DYNA, tested trench depths of 0, 10, 16, and 22 m against a fixed blast depth of 15 m. PPV fell by 46% at 10 m, 62% at 16 m, and 66% at 22 m. The largest gain came by 16 m, after which the response flattened. In rock engineering terms, this is the signature of diminishing returns: once the trench is deep enough to interrupt a large share of the transmitted wave energy, further excavation adds only a small extra barrier while increasing construction effort and cost.
Why the vibration barrier worked better than deeper excavation alone
Blast-induced ground motion travels through rock as a stress wave, and a trench can interrupt, scatter, and dissipate part of that energy before it reaches a nearby structure. The closer the trench comes to the effective depth of the wave path, the more of the dynamic load is stripped away before it reaches the receptor. Here, the 16 m trench appears to have intercepted the vibration field at a useful point, trimming PPV enough to improve foundation-level safety for buildings close to the blast zone.
The model does not support the idea that deeper is always better. The 22 m trench improved PPV only modestly beyond the 16 m configuration, which means the extra excavation provided little additional protection for surface structures. For mine planning, that matters because trench depth cannot be justified on vibration reduction alone if the incremental benefit is small and the cost grows quickly with depth.
A single sentence captures the core result: the trench helped buildings, but it did not rescue the slope.
Slope stability stayed below the failure line under blast loading
Under undrained conditions with blast vibration applied as a dynamic load, the Factor of Safety remained below 1.0 in every configuration, ranging from 0.101 to 0.105. Those values are not close to stability; they indicate a slope that cannot stand under the modeled loading regime. The trench depth, despite its clear effect on structural PPV, had no practical influence on that outcome.
The modeling also identified a critical PPV threshold below the lowest value tested, 2.68 mm/s. In other words, even the reduced vibration levels achieved by trenching remained above the range at which the slope could be expected to remain stable under the assumptions used in the analysis. The geometry and geotechnical condition of the slope were therefore more decisive than the vibration attenuation achieved by the trench alone.
This result reflects a common challenge in blast-adjacent excavation: the same control measure may protect one receptor while leaving another exposed. Surface buildings respond to transmitted vibration, but slopes can fail through a combination of dynamic stress, pore-pressure condition, and inherent weakness in the rock mass. If drainage is poor and the slope is already near instability, cutting vibration by half may still leave the system vulnerable to collapse.
What the Koidu data mean for mine risk management
The study points toward a layered mitigation strategy rather than a single fix. Trenching has a legitimate role when the priority is reducing vibration transmission to nearby infrastructure, especially where buildings sit close to the blast source. It is not, by itself, a slope-stabilization tool.
For operations with similar geology and blast geometry, the more realistic path is integration: trenching combined with drainage systems, ground improvement, or a redesign of blast charge parameters. Each of those measures attacks a different failure pathway. Drainage lowers pore-water pressure and can improve shear resistance. Ground improvement increases mass strength. Adjusting blast charge design can reduce the initial dynamic load before it ever reaches the slope face.
The Koidu Mine case is especially relevant because the site is embedded in a community setting, where vibration tolerance is not defined only by engineering limits. Local infrastructure, resident perception, and operational continuity all depend on whether the blast footprint is controlled at the source and along the transmission path. The authors framed the work as a response to that mixed burden: protect nearby structures without creating a false sense of security about slope performance.
The numerical approach also carries a broader value for mining regions in West Africa, where field data on near-field blast response remain limited. Explicit-dynamics modeling cannot replace site measurements, but it can narrow the range of plausible interventions before expensive field changes are made. At a minimum, this study shows that the vibration problem and the slope problem should not be treated as interchangeable.
Numerical modeling answered one question and left another open
The model gave a clear answer on vibration control: a 16 m trench delivered the best balance of effectiveness and diminishing returns. It gave a much less encouraging answer on stability: all trench depths failed to produce a safe slope under the simulated blast loading.
That gap should shape the next round of work at sites like Koidu. The remaining questions are not about whether trenching reduces PPV; they are about how much additional support a slope needs once vibration is partially controlled, and which combination of drainage, reinforcement, and blast redesign can raise the Factor of Safety above failure. Until those controls are tested together, trenching should be viewed as one piece of a broader geotechnical response rather than a standalone safeguard.
- • PLOS ONE article DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0362874: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0362874