Nonprofit Hospital Tax Breaks Outran Community Spending Across Much of the Sector in 2023
In 2023, nonprofit hospitals received more in tax exemptions than they reported spending on community benefit in the aggregate, and the gap was large enough to sharpen a long-running policy fight over what tax-exempt status should require. Lown Institute’s latest review of more than 3,000 hospital tax filings found $38.8 billion in industry-wide tax exemptions versus $37.1 billion in reported community benefit spending. On average, that worked out to about $12.8 million per hospital and 3.8% of total expenses.
The headline number only tells part of the story. Just over half of nonprofit hospitals fell short of the value of their tax savings when measured against reported community investment, creating a sector split between hospitals with deficits and those with surpluses. The difference was not trivial; it was uneven, concentrated, and in some cases extreme.
The Largest Systems Posted the Biggest Fair Share Deficits
At the top of the deficit list stood Mayo Clinic Hospital, with a $366 million gap between tax exemptions and reported community benefit. Tisch Hospital followed at $294 million, Stanford Hospital at $255 million, New York-Presbyterian Hospital at $248 million, and Massachusetts General Hospital at $219 million. These are not marginal providers operating at the edge of the health system. They are among the country’s most prominent and financially powerful hospitals, which makes the size of the deficits especially consequential in policy terms.
A hospital’s nonprofit tax status is meant to justify public subsidy through a measurable public return. When the return comes in below the value of the exemption, the balance sheet becomes a proxy for a deeper question: whether tax preference is financing community health or simply preserving institutional advantage. In practical terms, those deficits mean communities may be forgoing revenue that could otherwise support care access, financial assistance, or other local investments.
The opposite pattern also appeared clearly. North Shore University Hospital posted a $167 million fair share surplus, Rochester General Hospital a $146 million surplus, and Englewood Hospital a $142 million surplus. These hospitals spent more on community benefit than the value of their tax exemptions under Lown’s framework, showing that the model is not inherently tied to one financial outcome. The policy debate therefore is not about whether surplus is possible; it is about why it is so uneven.
Concentration of Tax Breaks Remains Highly Unequal
Lown’s analysis also showed that hospital tax exemptions themselves are concentrated in a relatively small slice of the sector. The 30 hospitals, or about 1% of all hospitals, with the largest tax exemptions accounted for $6.8 billion, or about 18% of all exemptions. Meanwhile, 607 hospitals, or roughly 20% of the total, accounted for three-quarters of hospital tax exemptions nationwide. That pattern suggests that the financial weight of nonprofit tax policy is being carried disproportionately by a limited number of very large institutions.
This concentration matters because large systems often have the greatest ability to influence local markets, pricing, and access. They also tend to have the most complicated mix of revenue streams, acquisitions, and affiliated entities, which can make public accountability harder to trace from a single filing. When the largest tax beneficiaries are also the hospitals posting the biggest deficits, skepticism about the current framework becomes harder to dismiss.
What Lown Counted and What It Left Out
Lown’s measure of tax exemption includes federal and state corporate income tax exemptions, state and local sales tax exemptions, property tax exemptions, tax-exempt bonds, tax-exempt charitable donations, and federal unemployment tax exemptions. Its tally of community benefit includes patient financial assistance, subsidized care, payments to other nonprofits that support health, and investments in community health or social determinants of health.
The methodology excludes Medicaid shortfall and spending on professional education and research. Hospital systems often argue that these exclusions understate the value they provide, especially because Medicaid shortfall alone can amount to billions of dollars in a year. Lown countered that such accounting losses are often offset by other discounts and supplemental benefits and do not always translate into direct community health gains. The dispute is more than technical; it goes to the heart of how public value should be measured.
For clinicians and health policy leaders, the distinction is operational. Charity care for an uninsured patient, subsidized care for a vulnerable population, and a research accounting loss do not all serve the same function. A hospital can contribute to medicine in many ways, but not every line item advances community health in the same immediate way. Tax policy built around nonprofit status has to decide which of those contributions count and which do not.
Pressure for Transparency Is Growing as Federal Policy Tightens
Lown used the findings to argue for amended, not eliminated, nonprofit tax exemptions. The group called for greater transparency in hospital reporting and for spending targets tied to hospital size, the value of tax exemptions, financial health, and prior spending patterns. It also warned that hospitals face additional financial strain from upcoming H.R. 1 policy changes and said any such changes should be paired with short-term financial protections.
The timing is politically sensitive. Lawmakers and policy advisers have already intensified scrutiny of nonprofit hospitals’ tax status, especially when pricing practices and collections policies appear difficult to reconcile with charitable mission. Academic work has added pressure as well. A Health Affairs study published earlier this month found a disconnect between hospitals’ listed charity care eligibility thresholds and their relative spending across filings from 2013 to 2022, with spending aligning more closely with community need than with stated policy.
The current debate is no longer about whether nonprofit hospitals should report community benefit. It is about whether the reporting system is strong enough to show what communities actually receive in return for a subsidy worth tens of billions of dollars. Until that question is answered with consistent standards, hospitals with large exemptions and small community investments will keep drawing scrutiny from regulators, lawmakers, and the public they are meant to serve.