A medical tribunal has ruled that a GP may continue practising after circumcising a seven-year-old boy without the father’s knowledge, finding that the doctor was misled about who held parental responsibility. The decision turned on consent, documentation, and the credibility of the account given by Dr Balvinder Mehat and the child’s mother, who attended the procedure request alone. In a setting where circumcision carries legal and ethical weight as well as procedural risk, the case hinged less on the operation itself than on whether the clinician had been told enough to rely on the mother’s authority to consent.

The boy, referred to as Patient A, underwent the procedure at Bakersfield Medical Centre in Nottingham on 19 October 2022. His parents had married in 2019 but were separated at the time, and the mother wanted the circumcision for “spiritual and cultural reasons.” The father was not told, and he was not named on the birth certificate provided during the consent process. British Medical Association and General Medical Council guidance says doctors should obtain consent from both parents, which makes the practical challenge straightforward in principle but difficult when family circumstances are presented incompletely.

Dr Mehat’s case rested on the claim that he sought clarification before proceeding. He said he discussed parental responsibility with the mother on 17 October 2022 and was told directly that no one else had parental responsibility. A consent form signed by the mother stated: “All those with parental responsibility are aware of the procedure above to be carried out without any disagreement or disputes.” In other words, the paperwork presented a picture of settled authority and no family conflict, the very conditions clinicians are trained to look for before carrying out an irreversible procedure on a child.

The tribunal accepted that account. Its determination stated that Dr Mehat’s evidence was credible and reliable, and that contemporaneous documentation supported it. The panel was satisfied that he asked who had parental responsibility for the child and was told that the mother was the only one. She had signed the consent form, produced a birth certificate without a father’s name, and told him she was not married. Those details mattered because the validity of consent in paediatric care depends not merely on a signature, but on whether the consenting adult has the legal standing to make the decision.

One sentence captures the core of the case: the tribunal found no misconduct.

In its reasoning, the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service separated the question of consent from a separate allegation that Mehat failed to include the boy in decision-making. His barrister argued there was no case to answer on that point because the General Medical Council had produced no evidence to support it. The tribunal agreed and removed the allegation. For a seven-year-old, the limits of direct participation in a decision of this kind are obvious, but the allegation still had to be tested against the evidence actually before the panel.

Consent failures around circumcision are not abstract paperwork errors. They can expose children to procedures carried out without proper legal authority, and they place clinicians in the middle of disputes over family structure, religion, and parental rights. In this case, the tribunal’s finding suggests the doctor was entitled to rely on the information provided to him, even though the factual picture later proved incomplete. The wider clinical implication is plain: when parental responsibility is uncertain, the threshold for proceeding should be high, and records should reflect exactly what was asked, what was answered, and what supporting documents were seen.

The hearing was not the first time Dr Mehat’s practice had come before a tribunal. It was his fourth medical tribunal. In March 2019 he was suspended for one month after his fitness to practise was found impaired because Nottingham City Council had cautioned him for numerous offences relating to rental properties he owned. In September 2019 he was suspended for one month after circumcising a baby without his mother’s consent. Then, in December 2024, he received a warning for derogatory comments about Muslim patients. Those matters sit outside the facts of the present case, but they frame the scrutiny now attached to his professional record.

A final point in the tribunal’s determination is the role of contemporaneous documentation. The consent form, the birth certificate, and the mother’s statements formed a consistent evidential chain that the panel accepted. In medicolegal disputes, contemporaneous records often carry decisive weight because they capture what the clinician knew at the time, not what emerged later under challenge. Here, that record supported the view that Dr Mehat had not knowingly proceeded without the father’s involvement; he had been told, and had documented, that the mother was the sole decision-maker.

Dr Mehat said he was grateful for what he described as a fair and proportionate process, and he said the allegations had originally been made in 2022. The tribunal’s decision closes one case, but it leaves the broader clinical issue intact: circumcision in children requires meticulous consent checking, especially when family relationships are strained or incomplete information is supplied. The safety of the procedure is only part of the issue; the authority to perform it is equally central, and future disputes will continue to turn on how carefully that authority is verified before the first incision is made.


Reporting by Dr. A. Nikhil Krishnan, MBBS for Medicine World Foundation, with additional data provided by BBC News — Dentistry.