Peer-led case presentations earned strong ratings across four academic years

Clinical teaching in paediatric dentistry often runs into the same obstacle: patient flow is uneven, and direct exposure to suitable cases cannot always be guaranteed. In that setting, a structured case presentation format can do more than fill a timetable slot. It can turn clinical scarcity into a learning tool, allowing students to compare diagnostic reasoning, treatment choices, and communication strategies across a wider range of examples than any single clinic day is likely to provide.

A four-year descriptive cross-sectional study examined that approach in fifth-year dental students, tracking perceptions from 2021 to 2025. Across 180 respondents from 241 eligible students, the feedback was strongly positive. The session design was simple but educationally dense: supervisors selected cases, students presented them with multimedia support, classmates discussed the management, and feedback followed in a peer-learning format. The structure mirrors a realistic clinical conference, but with the protective value of a classroom setting where mistakes can be dissected without patient harm.

One result stood out immediately. Access to paediatric patients remained the weakest-rated element of the experience.

Even so, the overall pattern was hard to miss. All 13 Likert items landed at a median of 4 or 5, with interquartile ranges of 4 to 5 for nearly every measure. Agreement rates reached 91.1% to 97.8% for 12 of the 13 items, while 71.7% agreed that access to paediatric patients was adequate. In a teaching model built around case discussion, that lower score is not a minor footnote. It reflects a structural limitation in clinical training itself: when real patient encounters are scarce or unevenly distributed, educational quality may depend heavily on how well programmes convert that scarcity into reflective learning.

Limited patient access shaped the weakest domain

The study’s clearest statistical divergence involved access to paediatric patients, which differed across cohorts with a Kruskal-Wallis p value of 0.018. Agreement was lowest in 2024–25, where 59.6% of students endorsed adequate access compared with 77.4% in 2021–22. The trajectory suggests that the educational model was consistently well received, yet its dependence on live case volume remained a vulnerability. In paediatric dentistry, where behavioural management, restorative planning, and communication with children and caregivers all require repeated hands-on exposure, lower patient availability can narrow the range of experiences students encounter before graduation.

The rest of the questionnaire moved in the opposite direction. Students consistently valued the arrangement of the sessions, the feedback process, and the learning outcomes generated by hearing classmates present their cases. That pattern fits the logic of peer-assisted learning: when students are asked to explain a diagnosis or defend a treatment plan to their peers, they are forced to organize clinical reasoning in a way that passive observation rarely demands. The educational gain is not only in hearing the answer; it lies in articulating why one approach was chosen over another, especially when paediatric cases often involve age-specific constraints, cooperation challenges, and family-centred decision-making.

Free-text comments reinforced that interpretation. Most responses were positive, with students saying they learned from colleagues’ cases and suggesting that the activity be introduced earlier in the programme. That recommendation is clinically sensible. Earlier exposure could allow students to build interpretive habits before they reach higher-stakes clinical placements, when uncertainty around paediatric treatment planning may be more difficult to correct. In dental training, timing affects not just confidence but pattern recognition: repeated case discussion can train students to spot developmental, behavioural, and restorative issues sooner, and to think through management options before they are under pressure in the operatory.

What the data say about paediatric dental education

The study’s design was descriptive rather than experimental, so it cannot prove that case presentations improve objective clinical performance. It does, however, show that students perceived the format as valuable over a four-year span and across multiple cohorts. That matters because educational interventions in health professions training often fail not because they are poorly conceived, but because they are too dependent on inconsistent clinical exposure or uneven supervision. Here, the case presentation model appears to have offered a stable pedagogic scaffold around a variable clinical environment.

The use of a questionnaire adapted from Bell and McKeown also signals that the authors were examining more than general satisfaction. The survey probed arrangements, feedback, learning outcomes, and overall value, which together sketch a practical picture of how the sessions functioned in day-to-day training. The consistency of responses across cohorts strengthens the sense that students were not reacting to a one-off novelty effect. Instead, they were responding to a format that repeatedly supported learning from clinical examples, even when live patient access was imperfect.

The statistical approach was straightforward and appropriate for the type of data collected. Likert items were summarized using medians and interquartile ranges, with Kruskal-Wallis testing used to compare cohorts. Free-text feedback was handled descriptively. Those methods fit the educational question being asked: not whether the intervention changed hard endpoints, but whether students found it useful, reproducible, and worth retaining within the curriculum.

For paediatric dentistry programmes, the practical implication is direct. Case-based presentations can help offset clinical unpredictability, but they do not erase it. If student access to paediatric patients continues to vary, teaching teams may need to pair peer discussion with more deliberate case selection, earlier introduction of the format, and stronger planning around patient mix. The educational signal from this study is encouraging, yet the weakest item in the survey remains the one most tied to bedside reality: students still wanted more hands-on contact with paediatric patients, and no amount of discussion can fully substitute for that exposure.


Reporting by Dr. A. Nikhil Krishnan, MBBS for Medicine World Foundation, with additional data provided by Frontiers in Immunology.