Perinatal depression screening was positive in most mothers surveyed in Karachi

A hospital-based survey in Karachi found a high burden of perinatal depression among mothers attending a public tertiary care center, with 198 of 262 women screening positive on the Edinburgh Postpartum Depression Scale at a cut-off of 10 or higher. The cohort included women in both the antepartum and postpartum periods, giving the study a broader view of maternal mental health across the perinatal window rather than limiting attention to one stage alone.

The mean age was 27.4 years, and the social profile of the group points to the pressures surrounding pregnancy in a lower-resource setting. Roughly 39.7% of participants were illiterate, 75% were housewives, and about 42% lived in households with a family income below US$126. Those figures matter because perinatal mood disorders rarely arise in isolation; they often sit at the intersection of socioeconomic strain, limited autonomy, and the emotional load of pregnancy and newborn care.

The EPDS result is especially striking. Screening positive did not prove major depressive disorder, but it did identify a large proportion of women with clinically relevant depressive symptoms that deserve follow-up. In a tertiary hospital environment, that pattern raises a practical question for obstetric care: how many symptomatic mothers move through antenatal and postnatal services without being recognized, counseled, or referred?

Maternal autonomy and partner support separated lower-risk from higher-risk mothers

Two psychosocial factors stood out as meaningful predictors. Maternal decision-making power was associated with a 72.5% reduction in the odds of postpartum depression symptoms, while emotional support was associated with an 80% reduction. During pregnancy and after delivery, the ability to participate in household decisions can act as more than a social marker; it can shape whether a woman can rest, seek care, accept help, and respond to early emotional distress before it deepens.

Husband support also emerged as a strong protective factor. Emotional support from the husband reduced the odds of antepartum depression symptoms by 45.8%, while abuse tripled the odds. Those findings fit a familiar biological and clinical pattern: sustained stress, fear, and interpersonal violence can intensify sleep disruption, impair appetite, and sustain neuroendocrine activation during a period already marked by hormonal fluctuation and physical exhaustion. In that setting, emotional safety is not an abstract concept. It becomes part of the maternal risk profile.

A single sentence captures the clinical weight of the finding: domestic abuse carried a far greater burden than simple family structure or income alone.

The association with abuse deserves especially careful reading. It signals that screening for depression in perinatal clinics should not stop at mood symptoms. Women reporting coercion, humiliation, or violence may need safety assessment, social intervention, and mental health support at the same visit. When abuse is present, depressive symptoms are less likely to reflect a transient emotional dip and more likely to reflect ongoing harm.

Access to care did not always mean lower depression risk

One of the more unexpected findings involved access to a healthcare facility. Women with access to a health facility had higher odds of antepartum depression symptoms, a result the investigators interpreted as possibly reflecting poor healthcare experiences during antenatal visits. On its face, the result appears counterintuitive, but the clinical explanation is plausible: contact with care does not automatically mean supportive care. Repeated visits can become a source of anxiety if the interaction is rushed, dismissive, painful, costly, or humiliating.

The study did not show significant associations between either antepartum or postpartum depression and several other variables, including household income, the husband’s employment status, domestic violence, and family abuse in the final analysis. Those findings should not be mistaken for proof that social hardship is irrelevant. In cross-sectional work, the signal from one variable may be absorbed by another, especially when psychosocial exposures overlap and move together in daily life. A woman may face financial stress, limited autonomy, and emotional neglect at the same time, making it difficult to isolate a single driver.

The design also places clear boundaries around interpretation. Because the analysis was cross-sectional, the survey can identify associations but cannot establish sequence or causality. A woman with depressive symptoms may perceive healthcare encounters more negatively, and a difficult care experience may also worsen depressive symptoms. Both directions remain possible. The same is true for access, support, and violence, which can influence one another in ways a single-point survey cannot untangle.

Still, the practical bedside message is direct. Maternal mental health screening should not wait for women to volunteer distress, especially when social support is weak or decision-making power is limited. In settings like a public tertiary hospital, routine EPDS use can bring hidden symptoms into view, but screening only helps if it leads to response.

Routine perinatal screening needs to include the social context

This survey makes a strong case for treating perinatal depression as a clinical and social problem at the same time. The strongest protective factors were not biomedical variables but relational ones: decision-making power and emotional support. That pattern aligns with what clinicians often see at the bedside. A mother who can speak freely, seek help, and rely on a supportive partner is more likely to navigate pregnancy and the early postpartum period with resilience than a mother who is isolated or controlled.

The high screening positivity rate also argues for system-level vigilance. With 198 of 262 mothers screening positive, depressive symptoms were common enough that selective screening would likely miss many women. Hospitals serving similar populations may need to embed routine mental health assessment into antenatal and postnatal care, with referral pathways that account for violence, family conflict, and limited autonomy.

The study leaves several questions unresolved, but it does not leave clinicians empty-handed. It shows that perinatal depression in this setting is common, that emotional support and maternal autonomy are strongly protective, and that health-system contact alone may not be enough if the care experience itself is distressing. It also shows that the social environment around pregnancy can be as clinically relevant as any obstetric variable recorded in the chart.


Reporting by Dr. A. Manasa, MBBS for Medicine World Foundation, with additional data provided by BMJ Open.