Animated tracheostomy video will be tested against a booklet in family surrogates

A randomized trial in Taiwan is set to compare an animated tracheostomy decision aid with a paper booklet for family members who must help decide whether a ventilated patient should undergo tracheostomy. The study, sponsored by National Taiwan University Hospital, is designed around a familiar bedside problem: when a patient cannot speak for themselves, relatives are asked to weigh a procedure with major implications for communication, care intensity, and long-term recovery while they are still under stress and uncertainty.

The trial will enroll adult family decision-makers of mechanically ventilated patients in the Respiratory Care Center at National Taiwan University Hospital Hsin-Chu Branch. These patients are already being considered for tracheostomy by the care team, which means the decision is not theoretical. It is immediate, concrete, and tied to the practical question of whether prolonged ventilation should continue through a tracheostomy or remain managed another way.

Family surrogates often enter that discussion with incomplete information. In the study rationale, investigators point to common misconceptions, including the belief that a patient will never speak, eat, or leave bed after tracheostomy. Those fears matter because tracheostomy decisions are not made on anatomy alone; they are shaped by expectations about function, dignity, and the possibility of recovery. A decision aid that translates medical uncertainty into understandable language can change the quality of the conversation before a family meeting even begins.

Knowledge gain is the primary outcome, not passive exposure

The trial will test whether the video format improves immediate tracheostomy knowledge more than an otherwise identical booklet. Participants will be randomly assigned 1:1 to watch an 8- to 10-minute animated video on a tablet or read a printed B5 color booklet. Both tools contain the same content, which makes the media format the main variable under scrutiny rather than the information itself.

That design gives the study a clean clinical question. If the animated format performs better, the difference would likely reflect how people absorb and retain information when it is delivered through both visual and auditory channels instead of text alone. In high-stress decision-making, especially when families are fatigued and frightened, cognitive load is high. Animation may reduce that burden by sequencing the information, making abstract risks easier to picture, and reinforcing key concepts through synchronized narration and subtitles in Traditional Chinese.

A trained nurse will then review the key points in the same way for both groups. Participants will complete questionnaires immediately afterward, during a single study visit. This means the study is not measuring long-term behavior change, nor is it following families through later decisions. It is focused on the early cognitive and emotional steps that often determine whether a surrogate can participate meaningfully in shared decision-making.

One sentence captures the core hypothesis: the animated aid should produce higher post-intervention knowledge scores and better preparation for decision making.

Preparation for decision making and anxiety will be measured at the bedside moment

Beyond knowledge, the investigators will assess Preparation for Decision Making, values clarification, and self-rated anxiety. Those secondary outcomes are clinically important because information alone does not equal readiness. Families may understand the words but still feel unable to judge which path best fits the patient’s wishes, prognosis, and quality-of-life concerns.

The study’s framing acknowledges that tracheostomy is a shared decision-making challenge in prolonged mechanical ventilation, not a simple procedural consent form. In Taiwan, patients ventilated for more than 21 days are transferred to sub-acute respiratory care centers for weaning, and about 39% of prolonged mechanical ventilation patients in RCCs undergo tracheostomy. In that setting, communication quality can determine how decisively and confidently families engage with the care team.

Anxiety is included for a reason. Severe stress can blunt recall, distort risk perception, and narrow attention to the most frightening possibility in the room. If the animated aid lowers anxiety or at least does not intensify it, that would support its use as a practical communication tool at a moment when families are trying to absorb complex choices quickly.

A tightly controlled content match puts format to the test

The intervention is built around identical content delivered in two formats. The paper-based version is a redesigned booklet that preserves the structure of the paper decision aid already used in the Respiratory Care Center. The animated version is a two-dimensional video developed by the investigators from the same script and adapted to the Taiwanese context, with both a Mandarin version and a Taiwanese local-language version.

Production details are unusually careful. Narration uses licensed AI voice-synthesis software, but only after the reviewed script has been checked line by line by the research team for medical terminology, pronunciation, meaning, and consistency with the subtitles. That level of control is important because this trial is not testing whether one version contains better information. It is testing whether the same information lands differently when it is animated.

Masking is not possible for participants or the nurses delivering the intervention, since the format is obvious. Even so, the analysis plan preserves some protection against bias: groups will be coded A and B, and the statistical analyst will not know which code corresponds to which intervention until the prespecified analyses are finished.

Why the trial matters for surrogate decision-making in prolonged ventilation

Tracheostomy decisions often unfold under time pressure, with families asked to interpret medical uncertainty while standing at the edge of a major transition in care. In that setting, a decision aid has to do more than present facts. It has to help surrogates form a realistic mental model of what tracheostomy can and cannot do, and it has to do so quickly enough to fit into the pace of inpatient care.

The study is also notable for its setting. It is centered in a respiratory care center where prolonged mechanical ventilation is common and the clinical pathway already includes consideration of tracheostomy. That makes the trial highly relevant to routine practice in similar inpatient environments, where clinicians regularly encounter families who need clear explanations rather than abstract reassurance.

Enrollment is estimated at 178, with the study scheduled to start on March 1, 2027 and reach primary completion by December 31, 2029. The trial is open-label, non-drug, and classified as health services research. Its endpoints are immediate rather than deferred, which fits the practical purpose of the intervention: improving the quality of a real-time decision conversation before the family meeting proceeds.

For now, the most important unanswered question is not whether tracheostomy is technically feasible. It is whether a short animated tool can improve what surrogates understand, how ready they feel to decide, and how much distress they carry into that conversation compared with a booklet that says the same thing in print.


Reporting by Dr. Aishwarya N., MBBS for Medicine World Foundation, with additional data provided by ClinicalTrials.gov.